Skip to main content

Challenge 7

This challenge closed on 04/12/2019. See below for the correct answers.

Program Alarm

PFFVT

.NFKGNH PYFUVR NI EYKBTH NSVHHNZ NTJ ANTJ TCVFSVFVC HUTJ PI JV ENJAUT PVM NTJ JONJFNTCUG NTJ RRB EVNF ANTJ JVTJ NHK KBP RU JVTJ NZ BJ HZNNH .NSVHHNZ HUTJ BJ PNX NTJ AU FNTCUG ENEANZZBGNF PZ SAUYVNGABG PI NFNT NAB JHNSSKH BJ ENUFJ NLVT U JKI ,PYNFKGNH ZNJHPH V AB NNFSV BJ MBT NFKH JBA ?JCPFGAN NYIKBE EYKBTH NM NIPVZ .HFNTCUG TJUM NKAUJABG BJ NLVT YYUM NM BH ,ZVNJ HUTJ FBR CK NAB JNH J’ANLVT NM JKI ,XBBI NEBG V BJ SAUTGJUMH EANZZBGNF EYKBM U PYYVKHK .CBFEHNLVN BJ PFJ YYUM EAV HKBUFKG SAUJJNS JFVJH YYUM JHBC NTJ ZBFR JHUYVAFKBW NTJ JVTJ NZKHHV BHYV H’JNY .ENJCNGFNJAU JNS YYUM HNSVHHNZ FKB XHUF YVNF V HU NFNTJ HJGNCHKH JFVZH RB HENFEAKT EAV HABUJVSUJHNLAU SAUBSAB BMJ TJUM JKI NFKGNH PJJNFC NFV HYNAAVTG FKB .ENANJTSUJ NI BJ ENNA PYYVNF HABUJVGUAKZZBG

.HNLYNHFKB NLUSFBR FNLNA YYUM NM MNFG H’YYNLBY ZUW BJ HANCCVT SAUTJPAV RU .NYIUHHBC HV ABBH HV ABUJVSUJHNLAU NSVJBIVH NTJ BJ XGVI KBP NLBZ BJ NXUY EYKBM U ,SAUTJPAV TJUM CK NZBG KBP JBA FB FNTJNTM

.FNLB JANH NM HCBBFJ RB FNIZKA NTJ ANLUS TSKBTJ TGKZ PFNL AMBE JU MBFFVA J’AHNBE PYIVIBFC JVTJ ?FVM NTJ AU NFNTJ NZUJ NZBH JANCH JVTJ NABNZBH FBR SAUXBBY NFV NM NIPVZ BH ,XK NTJ AU NFBRNI JU ANNH PYAB NLVT U EAV NLUJGAUJHUE PFNL HU NZZVFSBFC RB SAUYYNCH JVTJ .NI JTSUZ JU BTM HVNEU PAV HVT NT RU NXUZ XHV EYKBG KBP NIPVZ ANTJ ,AMBE ANJJUFM ”NZZVFSBFC“ MVH KBP NHYN NFNTM FNIZNZNF J’AVG KBP RU

.PVYC YKBR RB JYKHNF NTJ HVM JU JVTJ ENGAULABG HU NYBZ FKB EAV NSVJBIVH JKB ENYKF PYNLUJUAURNE J’ANLVT NM ,JANEUGGV AV HVM UUO AB NSVJKB FNMBC NTJ JVTJ PYNXUY HZNNH JU NYUTM .ENJVGUJHUTCBH PYSAUHVNFGAU JBS UO EAV O BYYBCV AB HXGVJJV NTJ .HNXVJHUZ PAV NXVZ BJ EFBRRV J’AVG NM PVMV HTJABZ MNR V JHKW UUUO BYYBCV RB TGAKVY NTJ TJUM .HFKNJBIVH NTJ AMBE SAUHVTG JANCH FNJJNI NI EYKBM NZUJ FUNTJ .HFBJVSUJHNLAU NTJ NHVNYNF BJ ABUJVSUJHNLAU JVTJ AMBE ENHBYG NM JVTJ FNTJVF EYKBM U EAV JAKT NYBZ NTJ AB HNGFKBHNF RB JBY V SAUHK NFV NM .BE KBP JVTJ JAVJFBCZU PYYVNF HU JU JKI ,HVM JVTJ BTM FNIZNZNF BJ EFVT NI JTSUZ JU BH ,NYCBNC RB JBY V ENMNULFNJAU KBP MBAX U .ENJVYNF NFV BMJ NTJ JVTJ PJUYUIUHHBC NTJ PYHKBUFNH NXVJ BJ NLVT NM XAUTJ U NHVG JVTJ AU .NYBZ FKB HV HJUIVT SAUYYNCH NZVH NTJ HVT SAUJBKD NFNM KBP FNLNBTM FB ,PYNXUYAK PFNL HZNNH TGUTM ,NGANEUGAUBG NSAVFJH PFNL V HU HUTJ FNTJUN .JHBC NTJ JV FBJUEN NTJ BJ XVNY NTJ AU JYNCH HU JU JVTJ PVM NZVH NTJ ,EUE PNTJ PVM NTJ JU JYNCH KBP ”NZZVFSBFC“ NJBFM KBP ANTM .NHYN NABNZBH ZBFR NSVHHNZ V SAUPCBG ANNI NLVT JHKZ KBP ENHUYVNF U BH JVTJ NXUY FBFFN SAUYYNCH V NXVZ BJ KBP NXUY J’AHU JU JKI ,NXVJHUZ V JHKW HVM JU RU ENFNEABM U ENGUJBA JHFUR U ANTM .CK JU ENXGUC NLVT EYKBTH U JKI ,FUVRRV JHBC XFBP MNA NTJ JKBIV SAUPFFBM PHKI BBJ HVM U HV NZUJ NTJ JV NGUJBA ANLN J’AEUE U .”ZVFSBFC NTJ“ SAUJVFJYURAU HJNULBH NTJ JKBIV NJBFM AB FNJVY ANTJ ,”UO AB HZNYIBFC PFBJGNWVFJ JANGHNE EAV HZFVYV NZZVFSBFC NTJ EAV O BYYBCV TJUM HZNYIBFC NGAVEUKS NTJ“ JKBIV NJBFM KBP BSV HXNNM RB NYCKBG V NSVHHNZ FKBP AU .NZ SAUFNTJBI HVM JVTM JKB ENFKSUR NL’U ,SNZ

Reveal the correct answer

Correct Answer

Meg, I’ve figured out what was bothering me. In your message a couple of weeks ago you wrote about “the guidance problems with Apollo X and the programme alarms and descent trajectory problems on XI”, then later on wrote about the Soviets infiltrating “the program”. I didn’t even notice at the time as I was too busy worrying about the New York Post affair, but I should have picked it up. When I first noticed I wondered if it was just a mistake, but it isn’t like you to make a spelling error like that so I realised you must have been copying a message from someone else. When you wrote “programme” you spelt it the way they did, the same way that it is spelt in the leak to the editor at the Post. Either this is a very strange coincidence, which seems very unlikely, or whoever you were quoting has the same spelling habits as our mole. In that case I think we have to take seriously the possibility that the two are related. I know you interviewed a lot of people, so it might be hard to remember who that was, but it is really important that you do. We are using a lot of resources on the mole hunt and I would rather that we closed down that investigation to release the investigators. Their time would be better spent chasing down the saboteurs. With the launch of Apollo XIII just a few months away we can’t afford to make any mistakes. The attacks on Apollo X and XI got increasingly sophisticated. While it seems likely that the power outage on XII was an accident, we haven’t definitively ruled out sabotage and our mole is convinced that it was the result of foul play. If you can’t remember where else you saw “programme” written down, then maybe you could ask Mike if he has any ideas who it might be. That spelling of programme is very distinctive and I have only seen it before in the UK, so maybe we are looking for someone that spent some time there in the war? That probably doesn’t narrow it down very much though given the number of troops we sent over. Whether or not you come up with anything, I would like to move you back to the sabotage investigation as soon as possible. If anything happens to Jim Lovell’s crew we will never forgive ourselves. Communications really need to be tightened. Our channels are pretty secure but with two ongoing investigations and hundreds of smart suspects there is a real risk our messages will get intercepted. Let’s also assume that the journalist from the Post will start getting curious and will try to eavesdrop. Usually I would recommend switching to a code book, but we haven’t set one up for this team, so we will have to continue with ciphers. Maybe we should double encrypt? Not sure how to agree on a system securely, but I have tried to suggest one here by concealing my recommended cipher in the key to this message. Seems to me that if you use that then read off the ciphertext the way hinted at by this paragraph then the message should be fairly secure. Harry

Searching close to home

JBNSAAOGHLHSADGYUGWSTEYFGAIRVAPTFMYARHVATAVQNTN
ODAFUAODCQLNAUQAZSEEFYDXPCNBFVQZIENZGFPVNUCTUTG
CGHEGLXPCGMWAXVETIOMASOTYBFTLKELWWATHGLVNDEGAHP
LOLQTGGLBLEDCFYHWFCUGYOJIDVRHHZMGDENOGQTKGBVYPL
KYAVFOQEOABYBGPLVQLGKICKUUSESUKFYSZFYEOHBEQFJNW
VXCLQDQBNUGPHVNHCGUTONLSQDOKROGLZSGYUVMWRGWHWFW
VUFJRCIFTZPGUVFPEYRUWKUGJRNULEETGCWWEPVVBBGFXAG
QPUSPXSKNIOZECFZBBJZVONCSLASJGLWZZDGNWXEUEJFOHG
BSDCRLUVLPDCNIHAQMNFYOYZTTTNWVMVGQJJWWFCZUBNBSV
EPRXSHHLKFSHUISMHSCHOCGTMMWNYQPYZLDTPBXMGZDKGCV
NBJGCKRPGAAEVAYSKMDQNLGSETVRASCMLJBXUMSYWQIZZZP
TZKENQLQXPHBITNDCXNYEUNPBHHTEDUTWSFQTVRYHEZWGTM
VNUAEVQFCQLQLAEMTGOPGRURSSSQOHOSWLGAHVKQZCFYFEM
FNSPVOVHWPQFFHAASTBHHVZTPGYWMFYKBNHUQTVQZYHMPQO
MRNUFBLQRBZDXSVAYSFAZDFAUGIWVFIBXFZGRMOLFPCYHFG
KDFEVJPYAQOKLYGOPLVINIMGCUBCWGFDJNDOJBVQUUQSAPV
PKUBVWQPFUGULRDCVHOWTETRSOJZSWUNOUGYVYYPWRPDJCO
USSQPKOHWSQSJNYGWYNTRCJKMMFTUBWFCMZXCSMPYRWOLIR
DGVJCFWFOUGNSUZZFVNHMFTUOICOHOTUXGHFXEQGOOQXJVY
RYOSDOGBHPGFCVGHRYISUUPWGFFKRFHWQPKUYSAAJGAUODU
YUWTNMBSFPNJYHLQFCVYTAQEWNNHLUSTICBSUEOEZBLNENA
QGICLBPDEYCSYSTBLBLDZPFBHYUSTXCIAFRVJIJWABTHQZN
WZFCQRXCWZZPAUCXUOJNLYGMEGNLWWZDFUNRGETFEOSLQPG
YCBQADGFCUEUSFZVANVVFSOFBOEMPJTMSWAZPRYSSUTKXNG
AGXATNPNZWAEPUJVYTTKUCSVQAUTXWAUYTIYRWIGHEHTFKE
FEUEWWSMTTHBHAEPCRMCWEETCIHWFXUNWAWEPKBCSAFPQBC
BUHCIYVYMSLMDUGLFXBNHJBWGXTCBCPFQTTALTXAHGRYKMS
FWLKRASDQDHGIGGMPKYBIAUGUYFBASZUJEMGQSHHXGPXSMN
GRZBSTOVNCCARZJSWZSMYHAYGGXOOHNGWQMVQYWKMNCIYBL
SFRRRNNVLZCVNHSSAPPAYSYZTHNAOWTPJXCGSTDKLIGWUZK
OOUQCTTTHPMVFPWXAMSFDDNUVZDDRURYOFSZDNBQKGLTFQC
NSWUYKRMWWAZGVJWFTSGNNWAUTKVCGJYGQPOCKUZYYHMSAY
AETGMHJICVZOBWGLCBYZDMVOYAHWZSKFYKGZFJAOVVMFUGF
YBSZBDGUMVWSRFFNWODDCLYOATEHRYBGFDPQNWYXTAYHSZU
GUDVEFHGFPQUFWGADUROBWFWVGFQZIRWUMQDSOGQFCLQNGX
QFJVGUSEUGBLUYWEMHHEOFUCMKQLKNGHSAWKRXLJQFGNOFW
YDQPIXYCAUPOFEHKMSQRHWSFECCHAKQZVZOYLQAGVWFKDHA
QQAVFWDXUQVWZATUAUFVQYVGBBMYHVGZHWEPVAYOKMYAVCC
UBLMLVRYOXDRCEHSUFEDINADMOBNLFGBSVVNWSPWGYUOLEF
DRVYGVAENKVBQWFYGOYMWTTGGCNCUJQEYVGTYPVFODFMARU
SNWDNLUSWTLFNCUNAWPETREALSWGGCHGETPRAMLKCJVIFAE
GAXKHNXJQEKOYPSATHUBKMQLJHYMAZSRBHGHMEKQWWNGTYX
TJYGLMFQACGWZFVAMCWQPMVXSWPZPTYCNSZTJBCGTXGGMWW
CGUEAFMALQSDGNQWECCZHBKUCUGOULOCKJHCSUYYUIKAWWF
FTACCSFEKFCCAUZZVYFAFZUPOGZPTQNNSWHQTAMWAHZPVFA
LYLOFPBBGTDDYPHQGFTIONHSESQBNQDUEFRCFYEEUROJXYP
YTJZXOFQAWRNOZRSPUHDSMTPFYIKMZNBMCJXLVBBOJXTKBA

Reveal the correct answer

Correct Answer

Harry, I don’t think we are going to need to look far for our mole, and I cannot believe it has taken me this long to work it out. You are right that a lot of staff here spent time in the UK, either during the war, or working with the ballistic missile experts in their atomic weapons program, but you don’t easily pick up weird spelling habits like that as an adult, you have to have been educated there. There is just one person I have spoken to about all this who comes from the UK, and that is Mike. I didn’t realise at first, his accent is pretty good, since he has been here since the mid-fifties, but as soon as you told me to look out for someone British I realised that the slight twang that I thought might be Bostonian was actually the remnants of an English accent. I was also thrown by the fact that his son died in Korea, but I checked and the Brits sent troops to help us out in that conflict and Mike’s son was one of the RAF aviators sent on exchange to the USAF. He died during a reconnaissance mission, shot down by a Korean MiG and the file shows that, before the carrier lost contact with his plane, he reported hearing Russian spoken over the radio channels used by the MiG pilots. Mike came to the US for the funeral and never went back. He was married, but I think his wife stayed in the UK. Not all marriages can survive something like that. Mike is still grieving, and I guess it has driven him a little mad. I can see why he is so angry about the possibility that the Russians are trying to sabotage Apollo flights and I guess he wanted to get the word out. I am still a little puzzled though. He might be boiling with rage, and grief can make you do strange things, but I have tried to imagine him writing it, and it just doesn’t sound like him. I guess he was trying to cover his tracks. Another thing is bothering me too. The call for a strike against the Russians seems out of proportion given the lack of hard evidence we have that the Soviets are behind the attacks. Either Mike knows something we don’t or he is prone to jumping to very big conclusions on very little evidence, and that does not sound like the profile of a NASA engineer to me. I wondered about getting a warrant to check out his place to see if he has hidden anything there, but judges take a dim view of fishing expeditions so I think I may need to be more devious. I could really do with having him out of the way for a few days while I search his apartment and make a few enquiries. Could you call him over to the Johnson Space Centre in Texas? An alternative would be Huntsville Alabama, but I feel very uneasy about inviting him up there now that we know he is a security risk. If I find anything more I will let you know, otherwise I will move back to the sabotage investigation like you asked. Meg